Freshly baked happiness in every bite Free Shipping Over $50 Freshly baked happiness in every bite Free Shipping Over $50 Freshly baked happiness in every bite Free Shipping Over $50 Freshly baked happiness in every bite Free Shipping Over $50 Freshly baked happiness in every bite Free Shipping Over $50 Freshly baked happiness in every bite Free Shipping Over $50 Freshly baked happiness in every bite Free Shipping Over $50 Freshly baked happiness in every bite Free Shipping Over $50 Freshly baked happiness in every bite Free Shipping Over $50 Freshly baked happiness in every bite Free Shipping Over $50
We will be closing at 4PM in Williamsville on7/4/2025 and 5PM in Lockport. Please do not place any pick up orders for after this time on July 4th. Thank you!
Peanut Butter Monster

Peanut Butter Monster

  • $5.50
Classic dough mixed with Golden Oreos and Reese’s Pieces.

Nationwide Shipping: We ship Monday through Wednesday to ensure your cookies stay fresh. Get your order in by Wednesday 11 am EST to ship that week!

Local Pickup: Pick up at any of our three bakery locations. Please allow 72 hours for large or special orders.

Delivery: Available within a 10-mile radius of our stores for $40.

Peanut Butter Monster

$5.50

Loved by Cookie Fans Across New York

“These are probably the best cookies that I have ever tried. ‘Sorry, grandma.’ Amazing food and very good service. Take my money!”
Vincent Cicatello
“These cookies taste so good I don't know how anybody just can't enjoy them!”
Vivian Rose

Follow Us for Weekly Specials!

Our specialty flavors change every week, so keep an eye on our socials. Just a heads up… Our videos are known to spark serious cookie cravings!

Privacy Policy -- Terms of Service -- Apply Now -- Blog

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa

    © 2024 Half Baked Cookies – All Rights Reserved. Created by COLAB.

    BUNDLE & SAVE
    4-pack
    $20 (Save 10%)
    8-pack
    $38 (Save 20%)
    12-pack
    $54 (Save 20%)