Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite Freshly baked happiness in every bite
Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter

  • $5.50
Thick peanut butter cookie, perfectly dense, not too sweet.

Nationwide Shipping: We ship Monday through Wednesday to ensure your cookies stay fresh. Get your order in by Wednesday 11 am EST to ship that week!

Local Pickup: Pick up at any of our three bakery locations. Please allow 72 hours for large or special orders.

Delivery: Available within a 10-mile radius of our stores for $40.

Loved by Cookie Fans Across New York

“These are probably the best cookies that I have ever tried. ‘Sorry, grandma.’ Amazing food and very good service. Take my money!”
Vincent Cicatello
“These cookies taste so good I don't know how anybody just can't enjoy them!”
Vivian Rose

Follow Us for Weekly Specials!

Our specialty flavors change every week, so keep an eye on our socials. Just a heads up… Our videos are known to spark serious cookie cravings!

Privacy Policy -- Terms of Service -- Apply Now -- Blog

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa

    © 2024 Half Baked Cookies – All Rights Reserved. Created by COLAB.

    BUNDLE & SAVE
    4-pack
    $20 (Save 10%)
    8-pack
    $38 (Save 20%)
    12-pack
    $54 (Save 20%)