Peanut Butter

  • Regular price $5.50
Thick peanut butter cookie, perfectly dense, not too sweet.



Nationwide Shipping: We ship Monday through Wednesday to ensure your cookies stay fresh. Get your order in by Wednesday 11 am EST to ship that week!

Local Pickup: Pick up at any of our three bakery locations. Please allow 72 hours for large or special orders.

Delivery: Available within a 10-mile radius of our stores for $40.

Loved by Cookie Fans Across New York

BUNDLE & SAVE
4-pack
$20 (Save 10%)
8-pack
$38 (Save 20%)
12-pack
$54 (Save 20%)